View topic - Eli Manning > Big Ben

[Mug-Z Profile]

Eli has a super bowl ring and a SB MVP while Ben has a super bowl ring and would have had a SB MVP had the Seahawks pulled out a victory.

Eli stepped up and played great in the playoffs while Big Ben continues to choke.

Eli is the better QB for now but we'll see how things go this year.

Mug-Z

[Nick79 Profile]

Eli stepped up and played great in the playoffs while Big Ben continues to choke.

Ben DOMINATED the 2005 Playoffs, single handedly destroying the Bengals, Colts and Broncos! He CARRIED the Steelers on his back to the Super Bowl, even throwing in a season saving tackle for good measure, and even though he didn't have a good Super Bowl statistically, he still made key plays and ran for a TD.

[TheOldRanger Profile]

Ben makes plays under pressure like nobody else in the league. Watch him this year. I wish the season could start tomorrow.

[Hi5Steeler Profile]

hell yea

[stillhearted Profile]

who got their SB ring first?

oh, yeah...thats right.

[jason97673 Profile]

Tim Couch has a higher career rating then Eli Manning.

[Guinness Profile]

This is a ridiculous topic to even argue. Best of luck to Eli and the Giants - wish them all the best...I will gladly keep Big Ben wearing Black and Gold if I had the choice.

[gumband Profile]

So Eli has a super bowl MVP.....'n' who should have received that MVP......: THE DEFENSIVE LINE....hands down.....The voters don't have much balls 'nymor like when they voted Cowboys Linebacker Chuck Howley MVP in the Super Bowl : a) for his defensive performance....plus (I love this one) b) while playing on the losing team.....